The US workforce growth has essentially stalled without immigration, which poses challenges for economic expansion. A stagnant workforce means GDP growth must rely on increasing productivity rather than new workers. When this occurs, the economy’s output may increase only if productivity improves through innovation or technology.

Without productivity gains, GDP can stagnate due to a lack of additional workers for production. Over time, a stable or shrinking workforce supports more retirees, increasing fiscal pressures. While tighter labour supply might boost wages, the overall economy experiences slower growth, making productivity improvements vital for maintaining momentum.

Impact on Various Industries

Immigrants fill crucial roles across various sectors, from high-skill to essential, which are hard to staff with domestic labour alone. Their absence can create shortages in industries such as agriculture, construction, healthcare, hospitality, manufacturing, and technology. These sectors face the risk of labour shortages, higher costs, and reduced capacity.

Industries like agriculture depend heavily on immigrant labour, risking higher food prices without it. In healthcare, rising demand due to an ageing population could exacerbate staffing gaps. Sectors like hospitality may see closures or reduced service capacity, while technology relies on immigrant talent for innovation.

With recent Fed comments highlighting that US workforce growth is near zero without immigration, we should anticipate increased market volatility. This situation makes GDP growth almost entirely dependent on productivity gains, which are far from guaranteed. Any upcoming data on immigration policy or labor force participation will likely trigger sharp market movements, making options that bet on volatility, like VIX call options, a logical consideration.

We saw this playbook before during the post-COVID labor shortages of 2021 and 2022, which led to stubborn inflation. As a result, the market may begin pricing in the risk that inflation will not cool as expected, potentially forcing the Federal Reserve to delay rate cuts or maintain a hawkish stance. This environment suggests traders could use options on treasury ETFs like TLT to position for swings in interest rate expectations.

Investment Strategies and Market Implications

The analysis points to specific industries that are most vulnerable to these labor shortages, including construction, hospitality, and agriculture. The latest July 2025 jobs report already showed wage pressures accelerating in these sectors, confirming that companies are paying more to attract scarce workers. We should consider buying put options on sector-specific ETFs like the homebuilders ETF (XHB) or the leisure and entertainment ETF (PEJ) to hedge against shrinking profit margins.

Conversely, the only escape from this economic drag is a surge in productivity. This puts a spotlight on companies that provide automation, robotics, and artificial intelligence solutions. With businesses forced to invest in efficiency to offset a lack of workers, we could see outperformance in the technology sector, making call options on automation-focused ETFs a compelling long-term play.

All eyes will be on the upcoming productivity and labor cost reports for the third quarter of 2025. Last quarter’s productivity growth in Q2 2025 was a disappointing 0.7%, far below what is needed to sustain economic expansion in a zero-workforce-growth environment. Any further weakness here would signal economic stagnation, creating headwinds for the broader market indices.

Create your live VT Markets account and start trading now.